7 Ways Amillennialism Negates God’s Promises to Israel :: By Jonathan Brentner

Although Israel miraculously emerged as a nation seventy years ago, fulfilling many biblical prophecies, many today still reject the idea that God will keep His promises to restore a kingdom to His people. Those who hold to this Amillennialism position, often referred to as amillennialists, see no future for Israel in God’s prophetic program.

It has long been my contention that, in their quest to negate God’s promises to Israel, amillennialists glorify the church rather than Jesus. They make God’s future kingdom all about what the church does by making life better in our current world. Can you see how over time this might open the door to socialism as a way to accomplish this? This is happening today in churches with a long history of amillennialism.

This downward path, as I examined in an earlier post, begins with a discrediting of prophetic portions of God’s Word. By adopting an allegorical approach to Old Testament prophecies regarding Israel, along with that, amillennialists negate God’s covenants and promises with the nation.

  1. Amillennialism Negates the Abrahamic Covenant of the Land

In Genesis 15:12-21, God made a covenant with Abram regarding the Land. By causing a deep sleep to come upon the patriarch, the Lord emphasized that the fulfillment of this promise depended solely upon Himself and not the behavior of Abram and the descendants he represented at the time.

David later referred this covenant regarding the Land, later “confirmed to Jacob,” as an “everlasting covenant to Israel” (1 Chron. 16:14-18; see also Psalm 105:8-11). Because God based it on His behavior, it exists as an “everlasting covenant” as David proclaimed.

Has Israel ever realized the fulfillment of this covenant? No! The nation has never possessed all the land the Lord promised to them in Genesis 15:18-21. This leaves us with two choices. First, God has broken His “everlasting covenant” with Abram regarding the Land. Or secondly, God’s promise to the patriarchs still awaits a future fulfillment.

Amillennialism opts for the first alternative. However, this makes the Lord a defaulter on His solemn covenant with the patriarchs, does it not? And besides that, if He can renege on His promises to the likes of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, what does that say about His unconditional promises to us?

  1. Amillennialism Repudiates the Davidic Covenant

Amillennialism repudiates the Lord’s covenant with King David. In speaking of Solomon, God promised to “establish the throne of his kingdom forever” (2 Sam. 7:13). We see from David’s prayer in response to God’s promises that the king regarded the covenant as permanent – as something that would “continue forever” (1 Chron. 17:20-27).

We also see this covenant reiterated in the words of Isaiah as he promised that the Messiah would someday rule from “the throne of David” (Isa. 9:6-7) and again as the prophet later wrote that a “shoot from the stem of Jesse” would someday rule as king over all of the earth (11:1-5).

The angel Gabriel, when announcing the birth of Jesus, reiterated the promises of the Davidic covenant to Mary: “He will be great and will be called the Son of the Most High. And the Lord God will give to him the throne of his father David, and he will reign over the house of Jacob forever, and of his kingdom there will be no end” (Luke 1:32-33). This is not a reference to Christ’s headship over the church, but to His reign as King over Israel.

Scripture nowhere repudiates the Davidic covenant; it remains in effect!

  1. Amillennialism Contradicts Many Old Testament Prophecies Regarding Israel

In order to deny a future kingdom for Israel with Jesus seated on the throne of David, the Lord must renege on countless promises in the Old Testament regarding the restoration of a kingdom to Israel. Yes, amillennialists apply these prophecies spiritually to the church. However, this attempt fails to recognize the specificity of the promises of a kingdom to Israel as well as the large volume of passages that speak to the restoration of Israel.

And, they overlook the literal and precise way of how Jesus fulfilled the prophecies regarding His first coming.

  1. Amillennialism Disavows Jesus’ Assurance to His Disciples

In Acts 1:6 the disciples asked this question of Jesus: “Lord, will you at this time restore the kingdom to Israel.” At this point, they clearly believed the Old Testament prophecies regarding a future kingdom for the Israelites. If this was no longer the case, would not Jesus have made it clear to them?

His response, however, does not deny their underlying assumption of a restored kingdom for Israel, but rather Jesus simply tells them their timing is wrong, “It is not for you to know times and seasons that the Father has fixed by his own authority” (Acts 1:7). The Lord then turned their attention to the current task at hand: that of proclaiming the Gospel to the nations.

If, as the amillennialists assume, God had already rejected Israel, why did Jesus not make this clear to His closest followers? Why did He ascend back to heaven with the disciples still clinging to the hope of a restored kingdom for Israel? After listening to Jesus teach about the kingdom for the forty days after His resurrection, surely the disciples had a firm basis for assuming the Lord would someday restore a kingdom to Israel.

  1. Amillennialism Refutes the Father’s Promise to the Son

In Psalm 2:8, the Father makes this promise to the Son, “Ask of me, and I will make the nations your heritage, and the ends of the earth your possession.” Yes, Jesus will reign forever over the earth in the eternal state after sin and death have been forever vanquished. However, Psalm 2 makes it clear that sin exists during this time of the Son’s dominion on the earth, something not seen in Revelation 21-22.

Zechariah 14:9-19 clearly pictures Jesus reigning over the entire earth at a time with nations capable of rebelling against the Lord.

In Psalm 2 and in other passages, the Old Testament pictures a time with Christ reigning over the nations of the world before sin and death are eradicated in the eternal state. This fits perfectly with the thousand-year reign of Jesus in Revelation 20:1-15 followed by the destruction of Satan, the White Throne judgment, and the eternal state where sin and death no longer exist.

  1. Amillennialism Discredits God’s Character

In the midst of proving that the Lord has not rejected Israel, the apostle Paul makes this statement in Romans 11:29: “For the gifts and the calling of God are irrevocable.” Through Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, God called out a people with eternal, sovereign purposes. God will not be remiss in His calling of Israel as His people; it’s an “irrevocable” call.

The claim that God has now rejected Israel makes God a failure in His sovereign purposes regarding Israel. It casts dispersion upon God’s character, upon His faithfulness to His people.

I know that many will shriek at my above assertions, and in response many will attack me. However, God does not fall short on any of His purposes – and that includes His eternal design for Israel, as demonstrated through His covenants and large sections of the Old Testament dealing with His intent to restore a kingdom to Israel.

Though some will strongly disagree with me here, I believe I have a solid scriptural basis for my stand. After all, the apostle Paul expressed shock and great dismay that anyone would say God had rejected Israel (Rom. 11:1-7).

  1. Amillennialism Ignores the Miracle of Israel’s Rebirth as a Nation

Irenaeus (140 – 202 AD) wrote about Israel’s future rebirth as a nation is his work Against Heresies. In the eighteenth century, Isaac Newton wrote copious notes about a time when God would again restore Israel as a viable nation. Premillennialists since the beginning of the second century AD have predicted the rebirth of Israel, even at times when such an idea seemed utterly impossible.

This great miracle occurred in May of 1948 when the modern state of Israel came into existence. Only God could take a people who existed without a homeland for over 2,000 years and again make them a prosperous nation as they are today. Just as Ezekiel predicted in the sixth century BC, against all imaginable odds Israel now exists as a people with a land (Ezek. 37:1-14).

And, as Zechariah tells us, someday they will recognize that the One they pierced is indeed their true Messiah (Zech. 12:10-13:1).

I sincerely believe the miraculous restoration of the nation of Israel on the land God promised to patriarchs so long ago flies in the face of all claims that God has rejected Israel. This is not a matter of basing theology on experience, but of recognizing the Lord’s hand in fulfilling prophecy, in keeping His promises.

I reject amillennialism because it negates the Lord’s promises to His people and calls into question His character as a covenant-keeping God. It also overlooks the work of God in fulfilling many prophecies right before our eyes.

Jonathan Brentner

Website: Our Journey Home

E-mail: Jonathanbrentner@yahoo.com

Does He Still Feel the Nails? :: By Dennis Huebshman

While driving to work yesterday morning, I was having my usual conversation with the Father (prayer). This is a time every work day that I can converse with Him, either out loud or just in my mind. He hears either way, and it gets my day started off right. While I was talking to Him, I was telling Him (actually confessing) that I know I am a sinner, and am very much looking forward to being Home (Heaven) in my new body and with a new mindset. (Any emphasis mine – Note: there will be some fairly graphic detail about our Savior’s crucifixion and sacrifice later.)

Then, a song came to my mind that I have not heard in a while, but it put a real conviction on me. Ray Boltz and Steve Millikan wrote and released “Feel the Nails” in 2008. I went to YouTube, and listened to it once more. Its meaning grew more relevant when I consider how rapidly the world is turning away from Jesus, and the true word of the Father.

We are told about the antichrists and false prophets (preachers) that were present in the days that Jesus walked on this earth. We are also told that near the end time – just before the 7-year Tribulation – that they and their activities would increase significantly. Prior to just a couple years or so ago, satanic activity was here, and has been all along, but not in the open or publicized as it is today. Now, there are satanic statues in front of courthouses in several places in our country, and “Churches of Satan” are springing up, even in the “Bible Belt” States. Demons were portrayed in the movies, but always as fictional beings. The Bible tells us they are very real.

The LGBT (and all the other letters) are becoming more and more active and vocal, yet they are still in the minority as far as population is concerned. They just yell louder than the conservatives. Satan is a master at organizing confusion.

On the flip-side, anything that has to do with Jesus and Christianity is being challenged as somehow being “illegal,” and Christian Business Owners especially are being denied their Constitutional rights to not be forced into any situation that would violate their religious beliefs. They’re being singled out by the radicals, and some liberal courts are ruling against these business Christians. Several cases are being appealed all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court; but during the wait for a ruling, the business people are suffering financial destruction. Even some “far-left” radical members of Congress are calling Christians “haters.”

So far, we haven’t heard of any court challenges to any satanic organization or activity.

In the song, there’s a question: “Does He still feel the nails, every time I fail?” Also, “Am I still causing Him pain?” The final quote speaks volumes: “I’m tired of playing games; I really want to change. I never want to hurt You again!”

When anyone considers the pain of just the nails, we must also consider the whole crucifixion procedure. The Savior’s crucifixion, or “sacrifice,” was prophesied in Isaiah, which was written about six to seven hundred years before it happened. It was described in all four of the gospels as it happened; and if all are combined, we get a picture of just how terrible it really was. Crucifixion was not common during Isaiah’s time, but by the time of our Savior, the Romans had perfected the method to deliver the most pain and suffering possible.

Isaiah 52:13-14 gives an overview: “Look, My servant [Jesus] will succeed. He will be elevated, lifted up [on a cross], and greatly exalted; just as many were horrified by the sight of You; He was so disfigured, He no longer looked like a man.”

Before going to Calvary, Jesus was beaten and scourged unmercifully. It’s reported that some who were scourged died before being put on the cross. A special guard would use a type of whip that had multiple leather straps, and the ends contained pieces of metal or bones or other sharp objects for additional damage. Many times, vital organs would be exposed when the skin was torn away. A large volume of blood would be lost. A professional “scourger” would be able to beat someone to within an inch of their lives without killing them.

After this, the victim was forced to take their own cross (possibly just the cross-bar) on the “Via Dolorosa” (Latin for Way of Grief), which was a street in the old city of Jerusalem. It led to Golgotha, also called Calvary, where the crucifixion would take place.

At this point, Jesus was nailed to the cross, which added even more pain. The nails would not be driven through the hands, but between the bones of the wrist which contains many nerve bundles. A single nail would also be driven through the feet. Death was usually by asphyxiation, as a victim would have to “push” themselves up to be able to take in air. Each time, their backs would give great pain because of the scourging, and also the pain of the nails would be tremendous.

Eventually, they would be too weak to push their body up with their feet, and they would suffocate. If the crucifixion was to be “sped-up,” the soldiers would break the legs of the victim, causing a more rapid death. Jesus died before the soldiers could break His legs, fulfilling a prophecy that no bones would be broken in Him (John 19:36). One web source gave the average time a person would be alive on a cross as from 6 hours up to 4 days. Mark 15:25-37 said Jesus was on the cross from the third hour (about 9am) to the ninth hour (about 3pm) or six hours. Pilate was reported to be surprised when he heard Jesus had died so soon.

People have tried to say that Jesus only “fainted,” or was taken down before He actually died. The only problem with that theory is, if a Roman soldier would allow someone to come off a cross alive, that soldier would then take their place. Pathologists have studied the “art” of crucifixion, and have determined there would be no way for Jesus, as a human, to live through the ordeal. Especially when it is reported that when pierced with a spear, blood and water flowed, signifying death.

For anyone to believe that Jesus was forced into His death, John 10:18 dispels this. “No one takes it away from me, but I lay it down of my own free will. I have the authority to lay it down, and I have the authority to take it back again. [After all, He is God.] This commandment I received from the Father.”

At one point during His arrest, Peter drew a sword to defend the Master. Matthew 26:53 says Jesus told him to put the sword away, because if He wished, He could call “twelve legions of Angels” to rescue Him. Can you just picture the scene in Heaven of all the Righteous Angels just waiting for the word to save Jesus and destroy those who were killing Him?

If one would read Isaiah 53:1-12, they would see the prophecy of the sacrifice that would be given. Jesus fulfilled over 100 prophecies just by coming to the earth as a human. For anyone to deny He is the Messiah would be a fatal mistake.

Looking at all the above, how could I not feel totally ashamed of sins I commit? His pain and suffering was for Me! My guilt should put me on that cross, not the Son of God who was sinless. God requires perfection, and my blood could never attain that status. As with all humans, I have the “Garden of Eden Sin Nature” in me. Only the pure, spotless unblemished blood of an innocent “Lamb” would be worthy. Therefore, only God Himself could, and did, supply what was needed. By accepting this sacrifice, we have the “gift” of being forgiven, because of His pain and suffering He endured. To not accept this “gift” is understandably the “unforgiven sin.”

When someone gives you a gift, it’s proper to open it and accept what was given. To leave it unwrapped, or to refuse that gift would be an insult to the giver. This is the same with our “Gift of Salvation.” What Jesus gave us is worth more than all the treasure this earth can contain. We are offered eternal life in paradise with Him and with all our wants and needs taken care of forever.

Review Romans 10:9-10 for the only stipulations to having this treasure as your own. Confess, believe, have Faith the offer is genuine, and it was paid in full by our Savior. Know that we cannot buy, earn or deserve this gift. However, all who call on Him will be saved (Acts 2:21 and Romans 10:13).

Time is getting short; all the signs given by Jesus, Paul and others are here, and it’s getting more evil on this earth daily. The Lord could return for His Church (all believers) at any moment.

Once the believers are removed, this world will enter a 7-year period of wrath shortly thereafter. All, Everyone could avoid this tribulation period by accepting Jesus now. To think someone could call out to be saved as the Rapture starts is impossible. Consider the fact that it will be in the “twinkling” or “blinking” of an eye (depending on the translation) as told in 1 Corinthians 15:52. This has been calculated by people much more educated than myself as 1/60th of a second or less.

This world is temporary, yet some prefer what is offered here by the Prince of Darkness – Satan.

When you leave this earth, you will either be with Jesus forever, or scheduled for the Lake of Fire forever. There is no other option. No one is “good enough” or has done enough “good deeds” to earn their salvation. John 14:6 tells us Jesus is the only Way, Truth and Life which will bring us into the presence of the Father. Your choice, your decision; it’s on an individual basis. No one else can get you into heaven, no matter what false statements they may make.

Please choose wisely, and choose soon!

Maranatha

bdhuebshman@sbcglobal.net